Just a glance at the two rounds’ dimensions side by side illustrates the main thing you should take away from this extremely well-written article: The 44 Mag is the more powerful round. 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum: In-depth Comparison. If you want a faster velocity, you always have the option to choose smaller and lighter bullets. I just got a 24" contender custom shop barrel in 357 max.I am very impressed with the accuracy with my handloads in 357 mag and 357 max.I got the barrel from ed's contenders in ok. I am thinking of a rifle for my daughter. id go with the 44 mag for sure. As the shots are close-ranged and the shooter can often be a novice, measuring efficiency can, at times, be challenging. At 100 yards, which is amazing stopping power. * the 357 is a short distance caliber, 300yds max * the 38-55 is better than a short distance, 500m and with the right reload & good eyes is a 1000yd target caliber 10-04-2016, 12:19 AM #10 I could opt for a .44 rilfe, with my .357 revolver, … I would suspect that the max would depend alot more on a greater degree of expansion to be effective for hunting. Pick up a reloading manual and compare the sectional density of 35 caliber bullets and 44 caliber bullets. Apart from the recoil that is felt, it is also a factor behind the energy that will be transferred into the target when the bullet penetrates. Dennis. The accuracy of .357 Mag is also greater in such situations. The .357 Magnum cartridges were made to be used by the police department as they needed a better terminal performing handgun load in the 1930s. Still, you should remember that smaller barrels often result in heavier recoil. Copyright Complaints: Please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent: http://www.bellmtcs.com/store/index.php?cid=120. We want the right amount of velocity for any cartridge as too much velocity can make the bullet get away without expanding or fragmentation. Also, this caliber is better for longer range than a .45ACP..45 ACP users are mostly EDC personal defense carriers and those that love the big bores. Which of the 2 kicks less, and what are the pros and cons? Shortly thereafter, Dan Wesson Firearms The.357 Remington Maximum is a very efficient cartridge for hunters of medium game animals like deer and hogs. The.357 is categorically less powerful in terms of available foot-pounds and bullet mass. So, let us see how the two differ in terms of performance. What came from these modifications is the round that is still in use … The bullet is generally fired into a ballistic gel, which is said to mimic the human flesh or the target. It has been seen that a .44 Mag works better with a trail gun. We do think that the .357 Mag will be better at handling successive shots for something that isn’t used to shooting through a handgun regularly. The OP is from Indiana and if he reads this since his post is so old he should check out this web site. This damage is very important when it comes to a person who is using the handgun for self-defense or hunting. The recoil that a person uses will often depend on the model of handgun that you are using. Both of them work great for shooting, hunting, and self-defense. If we note these, then .357 Mag is a better choice to go for when it comes to self-defense. It may come up to about 600 ft. Lb. (Yes, I know a light .44 special will reduce recoil, but not as cost effectively, or as much). So, let us begin with it. The renowned ammo manufacturers do produce them and you will get them at all the shops. The Ft-Lbs of energy rating for the .357 Maximum was 1,200Ft-Lbs!!!!! The .44 Mag can be a little slower as it deals with heavier bullets, which results in heavy recoil. Both of the cartridges offer great power when it comes to home defense. She quit hunting with me, and the dollars went away. Understanding the differences can make you a better gun owner and … 76Highboy Reloading. 357 Magnum. The choice of buying will rest on you and the firearm that you are currently using. We think that that the accuracy of the shot will significantly depend on the experience and skill of the shooter. There is no specific difference in 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum when it comes to the trajectory in the 50 yards mark. Hornady 180 Grain XTP / H.P. If you want to go above 70 yards, the .357 Mag is much more accurate. I shoot my Max's (yes I have a DW Supermag and a Ruger Max) a lot and have shot 44 mags. You could also get her a 22LR barrel for her to practice with. My problem is that while I do have a .357 revolver to pair with a .357 rifle, I don’t have a .44 revolver to pair with a .44 rifle. It was introduced by Elmer Keith, along with the Smith and Wesson Company, by developing the .44 special. The accuracy of the cartridges differs in terms of recoil. This power ensures that the bullet hits the target, penetrates and then expands and then transforms into fragmentation. Note When readers/you click purchase through links on our blog, we may earn some affiliate commission. The first difference that we can see is in the makeup of the cartridges. At 100 yards, which is amazing stopping power. Maybe explain how the max was one of your choices. The kinetic energy that is present on the bullet is an important part of its stopping power. My only concern with the .357Max would be using a tough enough jacketed bullet that wouldn't fragment on impact. I guess I will probably get the 357 magnum, then wait on the Max conversion until she is done with the rifle. 327 Federal Magnum brass (Starline, QTY 100) The bullets used in this simulation were the 265 grain FTX for the .44 Magnum with a ballistic coefficient of .225 and initial velocity of 1600 fps, the .350L with 165 grain FTX and an initial velocity of 2100 fps, the 30-30 with a 170 grain flat point and the .357 with the 140 grain FTX at 2000 fps. This is the monster long round that is longer and badder than the .357 Magnum. 414 Super Mag Brass #1440: 44 Auto Mag Brass #1410: 44 Colt Brass #1400: 44 Mag Brass #4400: 44 Russian Brass #1700: 44 Special Brass #3700: 44-40 Brass #2400: 445 Super Mag Brass #1520: 45 Auto +P Brass #1500: 45 Auto Brass #1540: 45 Auto Rim Brass #1610: 45 BLANK 45 colt BLANK Brass #1600: 45 … The .35 Whelen is a powerful medium-bore that does not require a magnum action or a magnum bolt-face. The .357 Mag has higher velocity compared to the .44 Mag at a distance of around 100 yards, but they do perform quite similar at the 50 yards mark. As we have told before, both the .44 Mag and .357 Mag are mighty. You may never expect it at a distance of 500 yards, but we believe that a distance of 50 to 100 yards is a good measure. Besides, I'm sure there is some type of wording in the law about straight walled cartridges. The 20+ Best Kayaks of 2020 – Reviewed & Compared in... Top 10+ Best Layout Blinds – Reviews And Buying Guide 2020. Recoil is also a factor that affects accuracy. Compared to the .357, the .44 was loaded to a higher pressure, which increased its velocity. In particular, the company has souped-up the specialized hunting ammo for excellent velocities, especially in pistol cartridges. I could see .357 magnum in a lever gun but the max is rather an exotic choice for ammo, as like the man said, the 44 would be much simpler to buy ammo for, and probably even alot easier to find components for, to reload. This indicates what we already knew: The 44 magnum is much more powerful than the 357 magnum. As we said, both the loads are quite popular among people who use their handgun for self-defense when accuracy is expected to be maximum. The .357 Mag is smaller compared to the .44 Mag. So, here are some of the things that we noticed in them. We will always advise you to take help from the internet to buy different kinds of ammunition. Just a function of barrel twist. When tested at 50 yards, it resulted in being 500 ft. Lb. The .357 Mag cartridges are nothing less; they also … The model of handgun that you are using will also be a factor when it comes to the recoil. Both are moving for their … As the .357 barrel length is shortened, the 10mm starts to shine. I started looking for a lever action but that article really convinced me to think about a 357 max barrel for my encore instead...... Or maybe both. It has been seen that the .357 Mag and the .44 Mag doesn’t have much difference when it comes to ballistic coefficients. When I was first told about the .357 Maximum. You should also note that the length of the gun barrel may also have a role in the velocity of the bullet. It was once the most powerful handgun cartridge in the world, as a matter of fact, even if it only held … He can shoot the max rounds for deer, the magnum rounds for things like coyoes, and use .38 specials for plinking and varmints. The market nich I see for the 357 maximum is it has far superior 200 yard ballistics than a 357 or 44 magnum, but significantly less recoil than 444 or 45/70 for the straightwall states. Came out in early 80’s. Both of them have been popular among people who need it for self-defense, and we can see the reason. Doing so it make the .357 max more attractive. I would really like to see a .357 max in a lever gun but the custom work to get there is slowing me down. If a bullet expands rapidly and turns into fragmentation, then it may stop before penetrating well. (But it does not, however, get there). I would go to with the 44 if I had to choose. You'll be hard pressed to find .357 Maximum in the local shop. I specialize in Thompson Center barrels but also rechamber CVA, H&R, and the new Henry single shots in .357 Magnum to .357 Maximum, .350 Legend, and a number of other .35 caliber cartridges such … We have divided it into different points so that it is easier for you to understand. I am also getting stuff piled up to reload. It should also be noted that the design of the bullet will also be a factor in penetration. The .44 Mag has greater recoil than compared to .357 Mag. is best used with scopes in the 4x range, although irons and red-dot sights are also great. The internet is the best place that helps you to consult about the choice. 357 magnum is a classic revolver round, while the other is a modern semiautomatic cartridge. They were slick enough to put in limitaions. It’s 357 Magnum vs 44 Magnum time! Still decent enough accuracy but beyond that, more like a prayer to hit target! Also, if you want a firearm that is concealed, then we will recommend you to get the .357 Mag as it can fit smaller bullets and you can use it in firearms that you can hide. When a handgun is for self-defense, you will want to use it successively when you shoot. One of the common ways of calculating it is through a ballistics calculator in which the weight of the bullet, powder charge, the firearm weight, and the muzzle velocity are kept as factors. In my opinion the Max is less recoil then the 44's hands down. which is quite good. This means that hunters are able to control the firearm much better, making more accurate and … This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. This is the link to Paul's patreon account. If you are someone who is using a handgun for the first time, then you will never want to experience heavy recoil as it may prevent you from shooting successively. Bullet selection for the .357 Maximum is a little different than one would think for a cartridge with straight walls and smallish case capacity. Maybe explain how the max was one of your choices. So, the cartridge that you choose should also come with great accuracy. The obvious advantages of the max are flatter trajectory and you can shoot .38s & .357mags which is great for low recoil and cost control. So, when you go camping or hunting, it is better to take .44 Mags with you rather than .357 Mags. round, the first thing out of my mouth was, “I wonder how they avoided the forcing cone erosion?” The guy who told me about it just shrugged. It was a great idea for its intended purpose, silhouette competition. Their new Raging Hunterhas been steadily increasing in popularity and starting this month, they are pr… He must have been talking... Summer months are perfect to make the most use of your backyard and patio. Any standard weight .357Mag handgun bullet probably wouldn't do. Reply. Planning a quick trip to the mountain skis? That has about changed my mind. Most hunters who use a “traditional” straight-walled case are going to be using .44 Magnum. But my daughter really wants a deer rifle. Be that as it may, the .357 Maximum's undeniable advantage over the more conventional magnum revolver cartridges lies in its high velocity and flat trajectory. As the neck is longer in the .44 Mag, it can hold bullets of heavier grain compared to the .357 Mag. As the velocity drives the bullet, it should also have to stop power. The later one has a more voluminous cartridge, which helps store more gun powder, and it is also able to take better pressure after ignition. “I don't know,” he … The .357 Max is barrel twist dependent for accuracy. It did not fail because it was a bad idea, not everything does. Indiana is allowing handgun cartidges. The impact is much heavier, which leads to better damage. Dont kick bad at all. Since i posted this, I have not purchased a rifle for my daughter. By now, we have talked about the overall performance of the cartridges, both of which are quite popular among handgun users. I am thinking one for my contender, in a 16" carbine. Here we will learn about the facets of the stopping power that helps these cartridges to work properly and because of that, they are considered some of the best cartridges for hunting and shooting. For example someone that lives in Alaska will probably go with a .44 Magnum, but someone in Michigan would use a Ruger GP100 .357. I'm sure either would do the job. I have been reconcidering the question again, since my boy hunts with me. Given a similar gun and barrel length, the.357 will always be easier to shoot and generally more accurate. Thanks! It's been discontinued, as far as I know. The reason I am asking is I reallllyy want the 357 max. A few years ago a friend of mine bought a New England HandiRifle in .357 Magnum. So, a person who is used to heavier recoil will get better performance from the .44 Mag. When he changes things up to compare the most commonly-used bullet weight for each cartridge, you can really see the difference. We wanted to clear out the air between them to provide a clear and comprehensive picture of the real thing to expect from both of them. In a rifle it essentially duplicates .35Rem ballistics, I suppose that cartridge is a dumb idea too, huh? The .357 Mag’s origins begin in the early 1930’s where the police force was in desperate need of a better terminal performing handgun load. Best Winter Gloves for Extreme Cold in 2019, Camping Gears & Accessories Black Friday Deals, Discounts and Offers 2019, 11 Best Boning Knives Reviewed For A Buyer in 2021, 11 Hunting Dog Breeds Proven Over Decades, Best Bow Stabilizer Reviews For Hunters And Shooters, Nordica Enforcer 93: Ultimate Review For 2021, 10 Best Baitcasting Reels: A Buying Guide For 2021, 10 Best Kayak Rack For Truck: Ultimate Reviews For 2021, 10 Best Gazebos You Will Love Buying in 2021, 11 Best EDC Backpacks: Ultimate Buying Guide 2021, Best Crossbow Bolts: Honest Reviews And A Buyer’s Guide 2020, Best Arrow Rest: 9 Reviews For A Buyer [Full Guide]. A bullet needs to travel well and have good penetration to be effective. The amount of velocity and the expansion power often lets us know about the energy that will be achieved by the bullet. Apparently it will soon be available in a new chambering. 357 Magnum Standard Load. So, to make all those things happen, the bullet should stop at the right time and this will depend on the cartridge. The .44 Mag. Recoil is quite an essential factor when you are using a handgun. 32 Smith&Wesson brass (Winchester, QTY 100) $ 23 66. Both of them have a similar ballistic coefficient, which isn’t great, just like several other cartridges that are used for handguns. Who made a rifle for the "max" anyway? The bullets weight and diameter is the way to determine the sectional density. If you go with the Encore in .357 Max you daughter can kill all the deer she wants with the .357 mag (you did say <75 yds) and you will have a 200 yd rifle if you need it. The only thing I have against it is the weight. Both of them have originated in the USA and people have loved them for a while. This is great for self-defense when you have to shoot a bear or any other predators. The velocity will also tell the probability of the penetration of the bullet after shooting. The .357 Maximum, formally known as the .357 Remington Maximum or the .357 Max, is a super magnum handgun cartridge originally developed by Elgin Gates as the wildcat .357 SuperMag. But if we compare between the two cartridges, the .357 Mag has less recoil compared to the .44 Mag. He took my .44 H&R, but no shots this year. So, it can be said that if you are new at using handguns, then you may use a .357 Mag, and with the time you can use .44Mag when you get further used to the firearm that you are using. If you handload then the 357 maximum in a TC Encore or Contender would be a dandy for your daughter. It's been a long time since I shot a .357 Maximum, and with variables involved, I couldn't tell you which kicks more. The only reason the 357 Magnum is not a preferred cartridge to a semi-auto pistol is ammo capacity. Shot out of our .357 Magnum Chamber.